I threw the teeth away. Thanks for all of the wonderful suggestions on what to do with my junk. It helped me come up with the perfect compromise! 

Tossed the teeth. Used the silver dollar at Starbucks. Threw away the little trophy, a few of the bible study journals, and other random trinkets. Kept the newspaper clippings, the letter I wrote to my second grade friend, and some of the journals. 

Perfect.